Over at seekingalpha.com Gary Gordon is asking the question : “Where have all the contrarians gone?” He’s looking at a list of 14-15 newly minted ETFs that are less than one year old and the rating they receive from Street.com. Not surprisingly almost all of them are labeled “Sell”.
If anybody ever wonders why successful investing is hard, then here is his answer. It requires you to look beyond the prevailing current doom & gloom. This means you need to have courage. Courage and faith.
During good times most people will agree with you and say “Amen” when you tell them that to be successful you need to be buy when there is blood on the Street. Alas, when there actually *is* blood on the street the same people will be out of their mind with fear and frantically pull their money out. “Preservation of principal” will be their new mantra. If you then dare to suggest that maybe now was a better time to buy than to sell, they’ll look at you like you’re crazy. Next thing you’ll hear are the most dangerous words in investing: “This time it is different”.
“The age of capitalism is over”, they’ll say.
“The US consumer is completely tapped out”, they’ll say.
And one of my favorites: “The US will be a third world economy soon.”
You know, every now and then, very few and far between though, the world does change and things *are* different indeed. For example, in the 50s, when the average stock dividend yield fell below the yield on bonds, people suggested to pull the money out of stocks, fearing that stocks were overpriced based on a valuation metric that had worked for a certain while. Needless to say, they would have been out of stocks since then and would have missed a very nice return on investment (plus they would have gotten killed in the 70s in bonds).
But can anyone tell me the when the last time was that people were this negative all over the place and there were actually right over the LONG run? Please do not point out the fact that in the Great Depression stocks fell 90 %, and based on that the bottom today may still be nowhere in sight. What these people usually don’t mention is the incredible bull run from the early 20s to 1929, when stocks on average went up 300-400 % in just a few short years. When they started falling they did fall hard, but they bottomed out around a 12 year low.
A 12 year low, huh? What a coincidence. That’s pretty much where we’re at today.
Do you think the world was looking pretty at that low? Do you think people generally agreed that the worst was over and better times would be just around the corner? No way. The night is always darkest just before the dawn and the economic situation always looks worst at the turning point.
Had you bought during the Great Depression after stocks had fallen 50 %, you’d have had to wait around 5-6 years with dividends to recoup your investment, despite stocks having fallen much further right after your initial purchase. Not terribly exciting, but certainly a far cry from the “25 years” that people always talk about when they discuss how long it took to recover your money had you bought at the top of 1929 right before the world went to hell.
What if this time isn’t different? What if things will bottom out this year and get better? How much return do you think you’d have made had you bought anywhere close to the bottom of the Great Depression?